http://www.benpezzner.com/DMB/BTCS/02-Rapunzel.mp3
I think I need to redo the outro solo... it's a bit messy. Thoughts?
Any comments on the mix? Should any of the voices be brought out more?
Thanks,
Ben
Rapunzel on the cello - please critique
-
BenPezzner
- DMBTabs.com Regular
- Posts: 345
- Joined: Sun May 09, 2004 11:42 am
- Location: San Diego, CA
- Contact:
I love the way you did this with the percussion. The only thing i would say is the percussion does sound a little shallow on top of the cello, i would nudge the bass up a little bit on the percussion, even though its not necessarily meant to be a thumping track, it should be a little deeper and louder imo.
I think the outro is pretty awesome and doesnt sound messy to me at all. Which was a little unexpected, as i was listening mid song i expected it to be a bit messy, for whatever reason. but it sounded spot on to me.
Its fucking amazing as always, but my new years resolution is to try and give you some kind of constructive criticism instead of just praising you.
I think the outro is pretty awesome and doesnt sound messy to me at all. Which was a little unexpected, as i was listening mid song i expected it to be a bit messy, for whatever reason. but it sounded spot on to me.
Its fucking amazing as always, but my new years resolution is to try and give you some kind of constructive criticism instead of just praising you.
~Andy (The artist formerly known as praisedave)
http://www.andymangold.com
http://www.andymangold.com
-
paulaitchison
- DMBTabs.com Authority
- Posts: 4278
- Joined: Tue Nov 30, 2004 11:07 am
- Location: vancouver , london, henley and birmingham,
very nice ben, very nice
Gervais on Rosa Parks "she was arrested but then that law was changed- but she didnt stop there, she started sitting in the seats saved for disabled people. unbelavable, she talked to the driver when the bus was in motion- did she have the correct change ready? - did she bollox!"
-
paulaitchison
- DMBTabs.com Authority
- Posts: 4278
- Joined: Tue Nov 30, 2004 11:07 am
- Location: vancouver , london, henley and birmingham,
dude i never really looked round your sight, the warehouse intro is mind blowing and i just had fun playing so right with your accapella,
truly awsome
truly awsome
Gervais on Rosa Parks "she was arrested but then that law was changed- but she didnt stop there, she started sitting in the seats saved for disabled people. unbelavable, she talked to the driver when the bus was in motion- did she have the correct change ready? - did she bollox!"
-
myxomatosis
- DMBTabs.com Authority
- Posts: 15555
- Joined: Thu Feb 12, 2004 11:14 pm
- Random movie quote to make you seem hip and "with it": You're entering a world of pain.
- Location: Over the hills and far away.
- Contact:
-
Coldchillin
- DMBTabs.com Authority
- Posts: 45703
- Joined: Thu Aug 07, 2003 2:48 pm
- Political views: Moderate
- Random movie quote to make you seem hip and "with it": Big Gulps huh? Alright...Welp! See you later!
- Location: Pennsylvania
-
Machtimus
- DMBTabs.com Authority
- Posts: 2208
- Joined: Thu Jan 20, 2005 9:37 pm
- Location: Bay Area
- Contact:
Little things that I'm going to be wary about, and I mostly wouldn't bring this up, but for your caliber it's the little things that can be the most annoying 
.
In some of the beginning phrasing when you're imitating the vocals, some of the ends of the phrases seemed to have a slight intonation problem (very minimal and especially well considering the instrument that you're playing) and I'm mostly thinking this is just a fault of my own ear. I'll listen over it again and pay particular attention to it. (Just listened to it again, and it is does sound a little off).
Most likely the mix, but I don't really like how much the percussion bit stuck out, it seemed a bit too overpowering for it outside the chorus.
You did very well with the multiple cello parts during the chorus, I felt like they complimented each other very well. Excellent job on that, definately a favorite part of this cover.
I agree somewhat with your solo being a bit messy. It's nothing a little more practice wouldn't fix though (or hell, I don't think practice is necessary, probably just another run through). The high run you do with the solo isn't necessarily my cup of tea, but I still appreciate if very much- you have quite the beautiful techinque on this instrument.
Overall, I think you are an amazing musician. I am amazed by all the songs I've heard you do, particularly with the cello. I've always been quite fond of it and I am very jealous of your skill in it.
.In some of the beginning phrasing when you're imitating the vocals, some of the ends of the phrases seemed to have a slight intonation problem (very minimal and especially well considering the instrument that you're playing) and I'm mostly thinking this is just a fault of my own ear. I'll listen over it again and pay particular attention to it. (Just listened to it again, and it is does sound a little off).
Most likely the mix, but I don't really like how much the percussion bit stuck out, it seemed a bit too overpowering for it outside the chorus.
You did very well with the multiple cello parts during the chorus, I felt like they complimented each other very well. Excellent job on that, definately a favorite part of this cover.
I agree somewhat with your solo being a bit messy. It's nothing a little more practice wouldn't fix though (or hell, I don't think practice is necessary, probably just another run through). The high run you do with the solo isn't necessarily my cup of tea, but I still appreciate if very much- you have quite the beautiful techinque on this instrument.
Overall, I think you are an amazing musician. I am amazed by all the songs I've heard you do, particularly with the cello. I've always been quite fond of it and I am very jealous of your skill in it.
Return to “Recording & Critiquing”
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 192 guests