As someone who has been playing for 10 years, performing for 4, & loving music since I was born. Im pretty sure Im qualified to critique a guitar & voice.Trippin Hillbilly wrote:I agree that he needs to chill out and learn how to take crit constructively but alot of you young guys around here like to give advice when you really dont know what the hell you're talking about. Not specifically in this thread but throughout the forum.
Well considering you couldn't figure out cannonball by ear...doesn't say much about your 10 years experience.jellyfish wrote:As someone who has been playing for 10 years, performing for 4, & loving music since I was born. Im pretty sure Im qualified to critique a guitar & voice.Trippin Hillbilly wrote:I agree that he needs to chill out and learn how to take crit constructively but alot of you young guys around here like to give advice when you really dont know what the hell you're talking about. Not specifically in this thread but throughout the forum.
My initial post wasn't directed at you bud. Just giving you a hard time. Peace yo..jellyfish wrote:You're right. I can't tab by ear & always relied on tablature. The internet has made us lazy by making it so easy to find the music online. And I dont think the ability to decipher music has anything to do with playing it. If that was the case, then Dave would suck in your opinion because he relies on a electronic tuner to tune his guitar. (he's said it 100 times he cant tune a guitar) Does it make him less of a player? Apparently, to you it does.
But, if you can tell me what I did wrong in this thread, let me know & I will leave this forum.
BTW, the first post I wrote him was a response to how he critiqued Borocks.
It twas but a Joke. Sorry, about the social barrier. In America we often kid each other.You_Enjoy_Myself wrote:jellyfish wrote:I don't want to be given a hard time. Life is hard enough.
WAAAHHHHHH! GOO GOO GA GA
i've met a dick of a phish fan.. he tried to steal $30 from me.jellyfish wrote:It twas but a Joke. Sorry, about the social barrier. In America we often kid each other.You_Enjoy_Myself wrote:jellyfish wrote:I don't want to be given a hard time. Life is hard enough.
WAAAHHHHHH! GOO GOO GA GA
And for being a Phish fan (hence avatar) you are dick. I've never met a Phish fan that was an ass, but since joining this message board all you have been is a dick.
Who did what?jellyfish wrote:You're right. I can't tab by ear & always relied on tablature. The internet has made us lazy by making it so easy to find the music online. And I dont think the ability to decipher music has anything to do with playing it. If that was the case, then Dave would suck in your opinion because he relies on a electronic tuner to tune his guitar. (he's said it 100 times he cant tune a guitar) Does it make him less of a player? Apparently, to you it does.
But, if you can tell me what I did wrong in this thread, let me know & I will leave this forum.
BTW, the first post I wrote him was a response to how he critiqued Borocks.
Guy...that's why I said for the person to go to a teacher, someone w/ experience and can sing themself. THEN practice your heart out.jellyfish wrote:NO, that guys needs to calm down. Please don't tell us how critique other musicians. And doing something over & over & over & over again doesn't make you good if you are doing it badly over & over & over again. It just makes you consistently bad. We are tryign to give him some pointer on his voice. The main theme was soften up your voice a bit, perhaps soften the guitar as well. IM sorry my critique isn't up to your standards.DmbFanJason wrote:Everyone needs to calm the Fiznuck down my brothas! the cover was good. Guitar was good. Singing was good. It does need to be chilled out a little bit though. But that could be handled in less than a day. Nothing to worry about.
Anyway, I find it funny how people "critique" on these boards. I have found that 1 for 1 of the people who just criticize(and not actually try to help the guy), are less than decent players/singers themselves. It's almost amusing sometimes to see some of the advice others give, especially w/ singing. All this "breathing" advice. Do you guys REALLY know what you're talking about when you say these things? Good advice would be to go to a teacher, someone w/ much experience and can sing themselves. And then just fuckin practice your heart out.
That's what gets you good...Doing something over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over again. And then do it some more.
You follow?
I need to listen, and take critique... man my mom is telling me : "You should forgive them, they didn't know what they said... I know they hurted you so much, please James... remember the child you were before this topic!" Return to “Recording & Critiquing”
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 157 guests
