Official Harmonica Thread

[fatjack]

my mom (music teacher) just said that the first and last chord has like a 90% chance of being the key and ive found it to be true in most cases... and fatjack... who is numbnuts in your post?

edit: ooh, i didnt make that list, i lifted it from an earlier thread. any corrections are welcome fatty

as a music teacher your mom should know that a song cant be "in" harmonic minor (or melodic minor as well). its really just a technicality, but songs are either in major or minor.

i already had this dicussion in a thread in the guitar forum

[fatjack]

my mom (music teacher) just said that the first and last chord has like a 90% chance of being the key and ive found it to be true in most cases... and fatjack... who is numbnuts in your post?

edit: ooh, i didnt make that list, i lifted it from an earlier thread. any corrections are welcome fatty

who ever said that a song was in the key of E Harmonic Minor..

in the original post Minarets is marked as being in the "key" of harmonic minor

[DMBFan63]

my mom (music teacher) just said that the first and last chord has like a 90% chance of being the key and ive found it to be true in most cases... and fatjack... who is numbnuts in your post?

edit: ooh, i didnt make that list, i lifted it from an earlier thread. any corrections are welcome fatty

who ever said that a song was in the key of E Harmonic Minor..

in the original post Minarets is marked as being in the "key" of harmonic minor

I know, I was commenting to him that a song was in E Harmonic Minor, which isn't right

[mangold]

my mom (music teacher) just said that the first and last chord has like a 90% chance of being the key and ive found it to be true in most cases... and fatjack... who is numbnuts in your post?

edit: ooh, i didnt make that list, i lifted it from an earlier thread. any corrections are welcome fatty

as a music teacher your mom should know that a song cant be "in" harmonic minor (or melodic minor as well). its really just a technicality, but songs are either in major or minor.

i already had this dicussion in a thread in the guitar forum

i just lifted the list fatty, i didnt make it.

are you gonna correct it or just say "DEERRRPP ITS RONG!"
are we back to Helping people 101?

a humble helpful person could have said in the first post "Im pretty sure minarets is in the key of Em, ive never heard a song being in the key of E harmonic minor."

notice the correction without arrogance? you've got all this knowledge but you are constantly belittleing people and presenting your knowledge and opinions as the word of god.


Now back to the thread. Anybody out there got some tips for bending with your lips and tongue? i cheat and do it with my hand when im just playing harp but when i play it along with guitar im having trouble bending

[fatjack]

are you gonna correct it or just say "DEERRRPP ITS RONG!"
are we back to Helping people 101?

a humble helpful person could have said in the first post "Im pretty sure minarets is in the key of Em, ive never heard a song being in the key of E harmonic minor."

first of all, i wouldn't have said "pretty" sure. i told you the facts, and you should know by now that any use of the word "numbnuts" (and its general equivalents) is not done so harshly

[mangold]

are you gonna correct it or just say "DEERRRPP ITS RONG!"
are we back to Helping people 101?

a humble helpful person could have said in the first post "Im pretty sure minarets is in the key of Em, ive never heard a song being in the key of E harmonic minor."

first of all, i wouldn't have said "pretty" sure. i told you the facts, and you should know by now that any use of the word "numbnuts" (and its general equivalents) is not done so harshly

i kno, im not mad... but you still havent given me the correct key...

[fatjack]

are you gonna correct it or just say "DEERRRPP ITS RONG!"
are we back to Helping people 101?

a humble helpful person could have said in the first post "Im pretty sure minarets is in the key of Em, ive never heard a song being in the key of E harmonic minor."

first of all, i wouldn't have said "pretty" sure. i told you the facts, and you should know by now that any use of the word "numbnuts" (and its general equivalents) is not done so harshly

i kno, im not mad... but you still havent given me the correct key...

yes i did douchenozzle:

songs are either in major or minor

so, if you had the powers of deductive reasoning, you would have been able to figure out that its in Em

[DMBFan63]

are you gonna correct it or just say "DEERRRPP ITS RONG!"
are we back to Helping people 101?

a humble helpful person could have said in the first post "Im pretty sure minarets is in the key of Em, ive never heard a song being in the key of E harmonic minor."

first of all, i wouldn't have said "pretty" sure. i told you the facts, and you should know by now that any use of the word "numbnuts" (and its general equivalents) is not done so harshly

i kno, im not mad... but you still havent given me the correct key...

yes i did douchenozzle:

songs are either in major or minor

so, if you had the powers of deductive reasoning, you would have been able to figure out that its in Em

[littlefriend]

Hi. I'm fatjack, and since I know so much about music theory that gives me the right to be a condescending asshole to all you numbnuts that don't, even though I could just be a condescending asshole with out my knowledge on the subject. The fact that I do know allows me to justify my shitty personality to myself and others. Numbnuts.

You could share your knowledge without the bullshit, dude. But more than likely you will just respond with more. It's cool. It's just how you are.

[fatjack]

Hi. I'm fatjack, and since I know so much about music theory that gives me the right to be a condescending asshole to all you numbnuts that don't, even though I could just be a condescending asshole with out my knowledge on the subject. The fact that I do know allows me to justify my shitty personality to myself and others. Numbnuts.

You could share your knowledge without the bullshit, dude. But more than likely you will just respond with more. It's cool. It's just how you are.

next time you shower, maybe you should consider Johnson & Johnson's No Tear Shampoo: maybe it would make you less of a whiny bitch

and you have no frame of reference to be saying that kind of shit. praisedave is well aware of what i mean when i say negative things to him. he knows i don't really mean it and it only drives him to get better anyway

[Brock]

[fatjack]

i know, i know... can't blame me for stealing such good material though can ya?

[mangold]

are you gonna correct it or just say "DEERRRPP ITS RONG!"
are we back to Helping people 101?

a humble helpful person could have said in the first post "Im pretty sure minarets is in the key of Em, ive never heard a song being in the key of E harmonic minor."

first of all, i wouldn't have said "pretty" sure. i told you the facts, and you should know by now that any use of the word "numbnuts" (and its general equivalents) is not done so harshly

i kno, im not mad... but you still havent given me the correct key...

yes i did douchenozzle:

songs are either in major or minor

so, if you had the powers of deductive reasoning, you would have been able to figure out that its in Em

how the hell was i supposed to know the E minor part of the E harmonic minor was right?

[DMBFan63]

are you gonna correct it or just say "DEERRRPP ITS RONG!"
are we back to Helping people 101?

a humble helpful person could have said in the first post "Im pretty sure minarets is in the key of Em, ive never heard a song being in the key of E harmonic minor."

first of all, i wouldn't have said "pretty" sure. i told you the facts, and you should know by now that any use of the word "numbnuts" (and its general equivalents) is not done so harshly

i kno, im not mad... but you still havent given me the correct key...

yes i did douchenozzle:

songs are either in major or minor

so, if you had the powers of deductive reasoning, you would have been able to figure out that its in Em

how the hell was i supposed to know the E minor part of the E harmonic minor was right?

I believe we both know the real answer to that question...


Anal lubrication.

P.S. I just got done work for the day which was unbelievably slow, so I had to let a little steam out.. anal lubrication style

[mangold]

are you gonna correct it or just say "DEERRRPP ITS RONG!"
are we back to Helping people 101?

a humble helpful person could have said in the first post "Im pretty sure minarets is in the key of Em, ive never heard a song being in the key of E harmonic minor."

first of all, i wouldn't have said "pretty" sure. i told you the facts, and you should know by now that any use of the word "numbnuts" (and its general equivalents) is not done so harshly

i kno, im not mad... but you still havent given me the correct key...

yes i did douchenozzle:

songs are either in major or minor

so, if you had the powers of deductive reasoning, you would have been able to figure out that its in Em

how the hell was i supposed to know the E minor part of the E harmonic minor was right?

I believe we both know the real answer to that question...


Anal lubrication.

P.S. I just got done work for the day which was unbelievably slow, so I had to let a little steam out.. anal lubrication style

anal lubrication style is the best style.