Missing chord in Captain...

Kickstand · Unread post by **Kickstand** » Tue Mar 11, 2003 6:02 pm

Hello everyone... This is Stand... I looked over the tab for Captain that is currently posted and I think, after listening to the album and an acoustic performance, that there is a chord missing from the "Roll me Back again" section. It's very faint and easy to miss in those recordings but I can hear it. I think that it would look like so:

e----------------------------
b-------------------2--------
g----8---4---3-----2----1--
d----x---x---x-----2----2--
a----6---2---1----------2--
E----------------------------

Excuse the poorness of this depiction...
Let me know what you think. Reply me with Q's. Later...

Speenis · Unread post by **Speenis** » Tue Mar 11, 2003 6:05 pm

Not to say you're wrong, but JKanter tabs everything from videos that he watches a million times to make sure everything is perfect.

Kickstand · Unread post by **Kickstand** » Tue Mar 11, 2003 6:13 pm

Right, I see what you're saying and I am no stranger to this site and the methods that these tabs are created. Is there a video for Captain? If so tell me so that I can watch it.

Brock · Unread post by **Brock** » Tue Mar 11, 2003 6:56 pm

hehe...
kanter has hours upon hours upon hours of video, some dating back to the band's inception... don't ask me where he got 'em tho

johntherevelator · Unread post by **johntherevelator** » Wed Mar 12, 2003 8:58 pm

TrippnBill686 wrote:hehe...
kanter has hours upon hours upon hours of video, some dating back to the band's inception... don't ask me where he got 'em tho

too bad he wont share :cry:

purljam999 · Unread post by **purljam999** » Sun Mar 16, 2003 12:49 pm

I do see your point kickstand, but its in the way you play it, in theory it should be like this

Code: Select all

e---------------------------- 
b-------------------2-------- 
g----4---4---3-----2----1-- 
d----x---x---x-----2----2-- 
a----2---2---1----------2-- 
E----------------------------

Unread post by **jkanter** » Sun Mar 16, 2003 11:30 pm

essentially that's exactly what I have up. I don't write double chords that way. Anyway, I am working on problems for that...peace

GeneD5 · Unread post by **GeneD5** » Mon Apr 21, 2003 4:06 pm

jkanter wrote:essentially that's exactly what I have up. I don't write double chords that way. Anyway, I am working on problems for that...peace

on your video you dont hold the 2x4 down for long..not criticizing, just trying to figure this shit out so i can play it for my GF on her BDay in 15 days

Unread post by **jkanter** » Mon Apr 21, 2003 9:33 pm

GeneD5 wrote:
jkanter wrote:essentially that's exactly what I have up. I don't write double chords that way. Anyway, I am working on problems for that...peace
on your video you dont hold the 2x4 down for long..not criticizing, just trying to figure this shit out so i can play it for my GF on her BDay in 15 days

I think I am just playing it a little faster than Dave plays it now...that might be why. In all honesty, when going for rhythm....I always sugest listening to Dave...regardless of how amazing anyone is...Dave plays it best...good luck man...peace

billywestom · Unread post by **billywestom** » Tue Apr 22, 2003 12:16 am

maybe this can help you guys out...

honestly i think that section of tab is set up kinda in the wrong order, because from the main riff you should go straight into the A chord, not into the B...so it is sort of misleading...

maybe that is one of the problems? i dont know, just see if this helps (scroll to the bottom to see my post)

http://www.dmbtabs.com/boards/viewtopic.php?t=2053

Unread post by **jkanter** » Tue Apr 22, 2003 1:31 am

billywestom wrote:maybe this can help you guys out...

honestly i think that section of tab is set up kinda in the wrong order, because from the main riff you should go straight into the A chord, not into the B...so it is sort of misleading...

maybe that is one of the problems? i dont know, just see if this helps (scroll to the bottom to see my post)

http://www.dmbtabs.com/boards/viewtopic.php?t=2053

What about this part????

Code: Select all

Lead Into "Roll me back again..." from Verse
E:------------------------
B:-4--------------2-------
G:-1----4----7----2----1--
D:-2----1----4----2----2--
A:-4----2----5----0----2--
E:------4----7------------
                  1

That's the main riff -> Chorus

billywestom · Unread post by **billywestom** » Tue Apr 22, 2003 1:33 am

jkanter wrote:
billywestom wrote:maybe this can help you guys out...

honestly i think that section of tab is set up kinda in the wrong order, because from the main riff you should go straight into the A chord, not into the B...so it is sort of misleading...

maybe that is one of the problems? i dont know, just see if this helps (scroll to the bottom to see my post)

http://www.dmbtabs.com/boards/viewtopic.php?t=2053
What about this part????
Code: Select all
Lead Into "Roll me back again..." from Verse
E:------------------------
B:-4--------------2-------
G:-1----4----7----2----1--
D:-2----1----4----2----2--
A:-4----2----5----0----2--
E:------4----7------------
                  1  
That's the main riff -> Chorus

right...i see what you have there, and it is right. but i think it is unecessary...if you just had the main verse riff...and then had another section called "roll me back again" or whatever with those 4 chords, i believe it might make more sense...just my opinion, maybe would cause less confusion

billywestom · Unread post by **billywestom** » Tue Apr 22, 2003 1:36 am

billywestom wrote:
jkanter wrote:
billywestom wrote:maybe this can help you guys out...

honestly i think that section of tab is set up kinda in the wrong order, because from the main riff you should go straight into the A chord, not into the B...so it is sort of misleading...

maybe that is one of the problems? i dont know, just see if this helps (scroll to the bottom to see my post)

http://www.dmbtabs.com/boards/viewtopic.php?t=2053
What about this part????
Code: Select all
Lead Into "Roll me back again..." from Verse
E:------------------------
B:-4--------------2-------
G:-1----4----7----2----1--
D:-2----1----4----2----2--
A:-4----2----5----0----2--
E:------4----7------------
                  1  
That's the main riff -> Chorus
right...i see what you have there, and it is right. but i think it is unecessary...if you just had the main verse riff...and then had another section called "roll me back again" or whatever with those 4 chords, i believe it might make more sense...just my opinion, maybe would cause less confusion

oh i forgot....and then you could say something like "to finish off section, stop at the E chord and go into main riff" or something...just a suggestion

GeneD5 · Unread post by **GeneD5** » Tue Apr 22, 2003 10:08 am

billywestom wrote:
jkanter wrote:
billywestom wrote:maybe this can help you guys out...

honestly i think that section of tab is set up kinda in the wrong order, because from the main riff you should go straight into the A chord, not into the B...so it is sort of misleading...

maybe that is one of the problems? i dont know, just see if this helps (scroll to the bottom to see my post)

http://www.dmbtabs.com/boards/viewtopic.php?t=2053
What about this part????
Code: Select all
Lead Into "Roll me back again..." from Verse
E:------------------------
B:-4--------------2-------
G:-1----4----7----2----1--
D:-2----1----4----2----2--
A:-4----2----5----0----2--
E:------4----7------------
                  1  
That's the main riff -> Chorus
right...i see what you have there, and it is right. but i think it is unecessary...if you just had the main verse riff...and then had another section called "roll me back again" or whatever with those 4 chords, i believe it might make more sense...just my opinion, maybe would cause less confusion

yeah, thats a great idea...go from the 7547, to a different vid/part of the
a-->e minor. Its just a bit confusing. Than you so much though kanter for this site, its fantastic! And thanks for the help billy

Unread post by **jkanter** » Tue Apr 22, 2003 6:18 pm

GeneD5 wrote:
billywestom wrote:
jkanter wrote:
billywestom wrote:maybe this can help you guys out...

honestly i think that section of tab is set up kinda in the wrong order, because from the main riff you should go straight into the A chord, not into the B...so it is sort of misleading...

maybe that is one of the problems? i dont know, just see if this helps (scroll to the bottom to see my post)

http://www.dmbtabs.com/boards/viewtopic.php?t=2053
What about this part????
Code: Select all
Lead Into "Roll me back again..." from Verse
E:------------------------
B:-4--------------2-------
G:-1----4----7----2----1--
D:-2----1----4----2----2--
A:-4----2----5----0----2--
E:------4----7------------
                  1  
That's the main riff -> Chorus
right...i see what you have there, and it is right. but i think it is unecessary...if you just had the main verse riff...and then had another section called "roll me back again" or whatever with those 4 chords, i believe it might make more sense...just my opinion, maybe would cause less confusion
yeah, thats a great idea...go from the 7547, to a different vid/part of the
a-->e minor. Its just a bit confusing. Than you so much though kanter for this site, its fantastic! And thanks for the help billy

I get what your saying but I thought it was easier to actually give the transition from verse -> roll me back again instead of just having it SAY that. Maybe I should re-word it to say "Verse -> 'Roll Me Back...' Transition" ???? Lemme know

DMBTabs.com

Missing chord in Captain...

Missing chord in Captain...

Who is online