Compare and decide for yourself...

[gcom007]

come on gcom, its not a big deal - there's no need for the attitude. I never even voted for whos was better because I think the idea is ridiculous. but that's just my opinion, I'm not bashing.

peace,
Ken

that was kinda my point, there were definitely errors and when I tried to point them out I got blown off and I just wanted to see how ridiculous it could get...

[gravedigger]

oh, ok well, even though you could be right and that your tab might even be more accurate, its the way you presented your case that appeared offensive. "Objection your honor! he's badgering the witness"

peace,
Ken

[gcom007]

oh, ok well, even though you could be right and that your tab might even be more accurate, its the way you presented your case that appeared offensive. "Objection your honor! he's badgering the witness"

peace,
Ken

if you guys only knew how much fun I have here...it's somewhat sad the level of entertainment I get from message boards...

[gravedigger]

I voted for Jkanter 6 to 1. you suck!

[gcom007]

I voted for Jkanter 6 to 1. you suck!

[jkanter]

I just for the first time actually took a look at our two tabs. For one.....that 4665xx is 100% wrong NO DOUBT. I can honestly give you no good reason why I have that up there as it is clearly a typo. The run down obviously goes B -> Bb -> A....NOT Ab. As for the C, right after that...you are also correct. The video I had tabbed from is far away and it looks like he had his 3rd finger on that 8. He probably used it to mute the low E so he could keep strumming all the strings(as he does in most songs).

The ironic thing is Dave probably realized that it was very hard to play it that way because he COMPLETLY changed it up when the song went through it's transitional phase from Crazy to Captain. I have edited my tab a little for now and will put up fully revised versions later on....peace

[gcom007]

I just for the first time actually took a look at our two tabs. For one.....that 4665xx is 100% wrong NO DOUBT. I can honestly give you no good reason why I have that up there as it is clearly a typo. The run down obviously goes B -> Bb -> A....NOT Ab. As for the C, right after that...you are also correct. The video I had tabbed from is far away and it looks like he had his 3rd finger on that 8. He probably used it to mute the low E so he could keep strumming all the strings(as he does in most songs).

The ironic thing is Dave probably realized that it was very hard to play it that way because he COMPLETLY changed it up when the song went through it's transitional phase from Crazy to Captain. I have edited my tab a little for now and will put up fully revised versions later on....peace

he's also playing something different on the "why should I part on the lilly's which I think sounds guess but my only guess at it is a transition a la crash with the C#m7 chord, what do you think?

[gcom007]

also, just to clarify, the only reason why I did anything I did with this is because there were such clear errors and I knew atleast two had to be typos and you just blew me off...no hard feelings at all, but I wasn't trying to be rude, there were just very obvious errors.

[jkanter]

also, just to clarify, the only reason why I did anything I did with this is because there were such clear errors and I knew atleast two had to be typos and you just blew me off...no hard feelings at all, but I wasn't trying to be rude, there were just very obvious errors.

I'm sure that to anyone who studies w/ the best musicians in Michigan would realize that there were CLEAR errors in my tabs but while I do understand that....the reason I blew you off is because of your post....let's look at it

First off, the Title

There is something seriously wrong with that captain tab...

Now is that really necessary??? Other people post suggestions and all they say is something along the lines of "Captain Tab Thoughts"

Next,

there is no way in Gods green earth that is right, and by some sin if it is, I never

Don't you think that "I was reading over the tab and saw some things that might have been wrong" would have done just fine???

Now,

The way I do it sounds infinitely better, are you sure you have that right kanter?

Good, I'm sure your way sounds good....post your suggestions right after the "I saw some things...." part.

All I'm saying is that there are MANY better ways that you could have gone about making your suggestion. Telling me I'm an idiot for putting something up like that(when I clearly state I am not a good tabber by ear) when all I am trying to do is help out the community is just wrong. I got no beef, but next time.....try and use your head to think about the way you are going about things......peace

[gcom007]

also, just to clarify, the only reason why I did anything I did with this is because there were such clear errors and I knew atleast two had to be typos and you just blew me off...no hard feelings at all, but I wasn't trying to be rude, there were just very obvious errors.

I'm sure that to anyone who studies w/ the best musicians in Michigan would realize that there were CLEAR errors in my tabs but while I do understand that....the reason I blew you off is because of your post....let's look at it

First off, the Title

There is something seriously wrong with that captain tab...

Now is that really necessary??? Other people post suggestions and all they say is something along the lines of "Captain Tab Thoughts"

Next,

there is no way in Gods green earth that is right, and by some sin if it is, I never

Don't you think that "I was reading over the tab and saw some things that might have been wrong" would have done just fine???

Now,

The way I do it sounds infinitely better, are you sure you have that right kanter?

Good, I'm sure your way sounds good....post your suggestions right after the "I saw some things...." part.

All I'm saying is that there are MANY better ways that you could have gone about making your suggestion. Telling me I'm an idiot for putting something up like that(when I clearly state I am not a good tabber by ear) when all I am trying to do is help out the community is just wrong. I got no beef, but next time.....try and use your head to think about the way you are going about things......peace

I read ya, sorry, seriously, I'll keep it real next time and hit up PM's first too if you'd like